Cindy's Horse Racing Website Index
Latest Articles
Latest Articles

 Black Eyed Susan Day
 Preakness Analysis
 Preakness Entries
 Man o'War Day
 Kentucky Derby Results

Charitable Man at the barn after winning the Peter Pan Stakes.

Photos courtesy of Nancy Rokos

2009 Peter Pan Stakes

Date: 05/09/2009

The $200,000 Peter Pan Stakes (G2) at Belmont Park, strategically placed between the Kentucky Derby and the Preakness Stakes, is used by horses ducking the main Triple Crown competition and preparing for a late invasion in the Belmont Stakes in four week's time. A field of just 7 three-year-olds went to post in this 1 1/8 mile trip around one turn of Belmont Park, on a cloudy day with a temperature of about 70 before just 5,264 paying spectators. Futurity Stakes winner Charitable Man was sent off as the 8-5 favorite exiting a poor 7th place finish in the Blue Grass Stakes last time out. In to challenge the Kiaran McLaughlin trainee included 9-4 second choice Imperial Council, fifth in the Wood Memorial after finishing second in the Gotham, and 3-1 third choice Hello Broadway, winner of an allowance at Keeneland last out after finishing seventh in the Tampa Bay Derby.

Jockey Garrett Gomez sent Hello Broadway to the front exiting the chute, and he was allowed an uncontested lead of as many as 8 lengths down the backstretch through fractions of 23.38, 44.89, and 1:08.93 over the fast main track. Charitable Man sat in second, in turn 2 lengths ahead of the rest of the field. On the turn, Charitable Man saved ground and gained on Hello Broadway who was already tiring from the fast early pace. At the top of the stretch, Charitable Man easily passed Hello Broadway to take over the lead. Imperial Council who sat 4th early, came out wide for the drive but was no match for Charitable Man, who cruised under the line 3 3/4 lengths in front in 1:47.13. It was another 1 3/4 lengths back to late-running 13-1 Brave Victory third, and 3 more to pacesetter Hello Broadway in fourth.

Pgm  Horse              Jockey         Win   Place  Show
 3   Charitable Man     Garcia        5.40    3.60  3.00
 6   Imperial Council   Prado                 3.00  2.70
 4   Brave Victory      Maragh                      5.30

Winning Time:  1:47.13

$2 Exacta 3-6                17.00
$2 Trifecta 3-6-4            88.50
Results Chart

Charitable Man gets a bath after the race. Winning jockey Alan Garcia said, "He broke good today. He was on the lead, and then he wanted to kind of slow a little bit and I saw (Hello Broadway), run away from him and I thought, 'Okay, let me see' and I thought it was going to be a clear trip. Quarter for quarter, I feel (Imperial Council) coming a little bit and then (Charitable Man) switched the lead and he started running, he took off. (When Hello Broadway was in front) I thought he was going to come back. I was sitting there, I knew it was a comfortable pace, comfortable time, but I didn't think that horse could keep going the way he was running."

Winning trainer Kiaran McLaughlin said, "(After the Blue Grass) he cooled out in five minutes. He disliked the Polytrack. We figured that, and Mr. (William) Warren (owner) was very kind enough and patient enough not to wheel him right back in the Kentucky Derby or the Preakness. He settled well. Alan Garcia deserves a lot of credit. He did everything right and rode a great race. We'll talk with Mr. Warren about the possibility of the Belmont. We'll take a look and see how the Preakness goes. But he is definitely bred to get 1 1/2 and he likes this track and he did it the right way today, so we'll look at it."

Shug McGaughey, trainer of second place finisher Imperial Council, said, "It worked out fine. I thought around the turn he had it, but he was second-best today. We'll take a look at a race like the Dwyer next for him."

Back to Horse-Races.Net main page

Want to keep up with what's new on this site?
Sign up for my weekly newsletter here.

On the Forum:

Search Horse-Races.Net:

©1994-2024,  Cindy Pierson Dulay   Privacy Policy   About Us   Search   Site Map   Add a Link   Advertisee   Suggest to a friend   RSS Feed   Follow on Twitter